Reviews

Reviewing Procedures

About the testing | Paraglider Testing | Paramotor Testing |Para200 Specs

These are reviews from a pilot's perspective. They are not certification tests since I don't do any significant SIV-type maneuvers with them. I try hard to be unbiased and accept no sponsorships or other remuneration from the product makers nor are advertisements accepted from those being reviewed.

If you are a wing importer/seller with a wing you would like to have reviewed, I would be happy to. Since its a lot of work and I make no money at it, I ask the following:

  1. I'm more interested in smaller wings so only want to review those with a wing loading over about 7 lbs/m. At my weight that means 25 m or less projected.
  2. Although I love soaring, my circumstance dictates more motoring and I'm a lot more familiar with what works best for that. Consequently, I have no interest in reviewing wings that are intended primarily for soaring unless their sellers feel they also make good motoring wings and other pilots have found that to be the case.
  3. A few wings exhibit oscillation under power. This usually has to do with how the motor interacts with the wing and is not a big deal. So although I may report it, you should try the wing with your motor. I've flown 3 wings with this behavior on my Blackhawk motor and my one of my wings did it when I flew it on a DK beat (old direct drive motor).
  4. If you would like me to review your wing, I ask that you pay for shipping to and from my flight location. Please contact FootFlyer.com here.

Paraglider

You can see from the flight test sheet that it takes some time for a full review and I can't always complete it. Sometimes a wing is around when I don't have a tape measure, hand scales, camera or GPS but I'll still report what I can.

Speed

Speed is measured by flying a constant altitude and using the following method. It's best if the motor has weight shift steering although tip steering works too (using stabilos). It must have enough oomph to fly me level at fast trim and full speedbar.

  1. Set the trimmers to their slowest setting. Without using speedbar or brakes, fly directly into the wind where it's easy to see left/right drift. That establishes the wind direction. Let the speed stabilize and take a GPS average for 5 seconds.
  2. Turn to exactly downwind and take another GPS average.
  3. Turn back to upwind, record the speed again (for verification). The rest of the test is done on this heading.
  4. Let the trimmers out (if equipped), let it stabilize and record the speed.
  5. Apply full speedbar, let it stabilize and record the speed. You'll now have 6 speeds: upwind, downwind, and upwind all trimmed slow. Then upwind at fast trim and upwind at fast trim with full speedbar. Subtract the upwind speed from the downwind speed and divide it by two--that's your windspeed and will be subtracted from your next three speeds to get an airspeed.

Handling

This is mostly subjective but a big deal is how much brake pull it takes, both pressure and distance, to achieve a 45 turn. For most wings that's approximately where the tip appears to touch the horizon. Higher performance wings tend to be longer and skinnier so their tips will be a bit lower while still in a 45 turn.

Some wings curl the tips to pull the wing over for a steeper turn. That also will cause a dive if not countered with opposing brake. Higher performance wings, namely high aspect ratio models, will generally spin easier too. I'll never get to test that on a lot of wings because I'm not willing to get them that close to stall without being on a dune.

When time permits (it rarely will) I'll try to quantify handling with a pull force scale on one brake toggle on the natural turn side (right turns for belt drive machines)..

Inflation

A couple things that can tell a lot about how well a wing comes up involves simply laying it out for a forward launch the trying to inflate it without using the A's. Also important are whether or not the tips tend to come up into the center and whether brakes tend to fold back a tip.

Unless the manual says otherwise (I've never seen one that does) I'll use the center A's on split A-riser wings.

Paramotor

There is a lot to test and some things to measure whenever possible. A lot of effort goes into testing machines and, although I love the flying, it's a lot of work. Sometimes I'll only get a couple flights on a machine that I'm trying out because of availability.

Thrust

Here's a tough one. I fly a machine that averages about 130 pounds of thrust, one that averages 95, and another that struggles to get 75 pounds of thrust. So I'm gonna stick with using climb rate and comparison since I can't carry a thrust tester around. Thrust tests, done at fly-ins where machines are tested WITH THEIR HARNESSES are the only valuable data. Unfortunately that is hard to find.

I try to do comparisons on the same wing but that's not always possible. If different wings are being flown in side-by-side climb tests then I'll subtract the climb rate of the less efficient (or more heavily loaded) wing. For example, one side-by-side test involved me under a Spice 22 with a Fresh Breeze Simonini and another pilot on a U-turn Acro 17 flying a FlatTop Simonini. I out climbed him by about 100 - 150 fpm. But he was way more heavily loaded on that wing. My power-off sink rate is about 350 fpm and his was probably about 450 fpm so I subtract that out which means that model FB has more thrust than that model FlatTop by probably 5 pounds. That's essentially irrelevant. Differences in thrust will vary within model, even on the same day and same place, by probably 10%. So, in my opinion, differences less than 10% are meaningless.

Weight

Empty weight is what we care about--weight of the motor, harness, prop, and any accessories that come from the factory as standard. In other words, how much it weighs ready to fly sans fuel. Of course we also have to lift the fuel so consider that an efficient motor will let you carry less fuel. On a 4-stroke, empty weight includes engine oil. An electric motor's fuel is in the battery which will obviously weigh the same on landing as it does on takeoff.

The plan is to put an accurate scale on a hard surface, weigh myself, put the motor on my back and weigh again. I obviously need a more accurate scale because when I tried the test several times, I got different results (by up to 4 pounds). Given that a few pounds can mean a lot, I'm not going to include my weight measurements until I find a better scale or method.

Sound/Noise

Two aspects will be commented on: the pilot's in-flight sound and sound from the ground. A DB meter is almost worthless if the noise it's detecting is not what's annoying to humans. A loud dog whistle is hardly a bother. Go to a fly-in and listen to the loud motors. Listen to the quiet ones. It turns out the DB meter doesn't get it in that regard. So until I find a DB meter that matches the politician's ear, I'll stick with my method: note which ones are quiet.

 

ParagliderTest.gif (19200 bytes)

Paraglider test reports would be welcome from experienced pilots on wings that have not yet been reviewed (must have no financial interest). Please download and use the above worksheet for consistency.

 

Paraglider Flight Test Worksheet (Word Doc)

 

ParamotorTest.gif (29407 bytes)

Paramotor test reports would be welcome from experienced pilots  on motors that have not yet been reviewed (must have no financial interest). Please download and use the above worksheet for consistency.

 

Paramotor Flight Test Worksheet (Word Doc)

 

 


© 2016 Jeff Goin & Tim Kaiser   Remember: If there's air there, it should be flown in!